I like the 1 vrs 1 bracket. It is time tested, and has worked for some of the biggest competitions in dance. You draw names at random to make the brackets so luck will play a wild card factor.
The cyper based looks good on paper but, I think would be a cluster in application. I just don't know how you would keep it from becoming disorganized and god forbid Tiny is competing you will never get the circle back.
I would hold a smaller comp or just have guys get together and work the bugs out before you go basing a competition on it. The dance sport guys have it down but, there dances and music are very structured.
.02

E